The word ryokan covers an extraordinary range. At one end: Tawaraya in Kyoto, where world leaders have stayed and where a single night costs more than most hotel suites in Tokyo. At the other: budget inns near train stations that share the vocabulary but none of the substance. Most travelers know they want a ryokan experience. Very few know how to distinguish between the tiers before booking, and that distinction determines almost everything about the quality of the stay.
This guide breaks down the ryokan spectrum honestly. What each tier delivers, what the critical differentiators are, and how STAYGO thinks about matching clients to the right property for their specific travel profile.
WHAT A RYOKAN ACTUALLY IS
A ryokan is a traditional Japanese inn built around a specific structure of hospitality. Guests arrive in the late afternoon, are met by staff at the entrance, and are escorted to a tatami-floored room where yukata (cotton robes) and socks have been laid out. Tea and wagashi sweets are served. Before dinner, guests bathe, either in the communal onsen bath or in their private one if the property offers it. Dinner is kaiseki: a multi-course seasonal meal, either served in the room by a dedicated attendant or in a dining room. Breakfast the following morning follows the same ceremony. Checkout is typically before 11am.
The experience is not about amenities in the Western hotel sense. There is no fitness centre, no lobby bar, often no minibar. The point is the bath, the meal, the quiet, and the attention of the staff, which at the top properties is far closer and more constant than in a Western luxury hotel. The concept is omotenashi: hospitality that anticipates before it is asked.
The onsen, the hot spring bath, is central. Japan sits on one of the most geothermally active regions on earth, and the mineral content and temperature of the water varies significantly by location. Hakone water, heavily sulphurous, has a different quality from the soft alkaline water of Kinosaki Onsen or the iron-rich water of Beppu in Kyushu. Part of choosing a ryokan is choosing whose water you want to soak in.
"The difference between a good ryokan stay and a transformative one comes down to two things: the quality of the kaiseki, and whether the bath is yours alone."
TIER 1: THE FINEST RYOKAN IN JAPAN
Tier 1 properties are those where the building, the cuisine, the water, the staff ratio, and the history combine to put them in a category of their own. There are not many of them, and they are booked months ahead. Prices run from ¥100,000 to ¥300,000 or more per person per night, including dinner and breakfast.
The most famous ryokan in Japan, and arguably in the world. Tawaraya has been operating in central Kyoto since 1709, in the same family for six generations. Its 18 rooms, each designed individually around a private garden, have hosted heads of state and Nobel laureates for three centuries. Steve Jobs stayed here. The kaiseki served at Tawaraya is among the finest food in Japan, full stop. The building is low, wooden, and plain: what you are paying for is the detail of the room, the temperature of the water in the iron kettle, the arrangement of the seasonal flowers. Bookings are made months in advance and require persistence. STAYGO maintains a working relationship with the property.
If Tawaraya represents classical ryokan tradition, Beniya Mukayu represents its modern evolution. Located in Yamanaka Onsen near Kanazawa, it is a property of contemporary design: low buildings on a wooded hillside, every one of the 18 rooms with a private rotenburo (outdoor hot spring bath) on its own terrace. The kitchen works in the Kaga tradition, the refined cooking of the Kanazawa region, and it does so consistently well. There are no shared baths at all, so tattoo policies never come up. The guest-to-staff ratio is among the highest in Japan. This is the ryokan that converts skeptics.
Built on the former villa of the Fushimi Imperial Family in Hakone, Gora Kadan keeps gardens maintained with the same obsessive care that once served the imperial household. The property holds to traditional ryokan form: private hot spring baths for each suite, rooms that look onto the gardens or into forested hillside, and a kitchen that takes Hakone's mineral-rich spring water as the starting point for its kaiseki. Hakone's mountain scenery and volcanic landscape are immediately at hand. It is worth more than one stay, since each season produces a different one.
Asaba occupies a site in Shuzenji on the Izu Peninsula that has been a place of retreat for more than 450 years. The current buildings are low and traditional, arranged around a bamboo grove and a noh stage that juts out over a still pond. Noh performances are staged for guests on selected evenings. The bathhouse is a significant piece of architecture in its own right, with water drawn from Shuzenji's ancient spring. Asaba does not market itself aggressively and is less known abroad than its quality warrants, which keeps it quieter than Tawaraya or Beniya Mukayu at the same level of stay.
TIER 2: EXCELLENT, NOT LEGENDARY
Tier 2 is a wide band covering properties that deliver a genuinely high-quality ryokan experience without the historical weight, room count exclusivity, or culinary distinction of the top tier. Many excellent properties in Hakone, the outskirts of Kyoto, Nara, Kinosaki Onsen, and Arima Onsen fall here. Typical pricing runs from ¥40,000 to ¥100,000 per person per night including meals.
What Tier 2 offers: solid to very good kaiseki (the gap between good and exceptional kaiseki is significant: Tier 2 properties tend to produce well-executed seasonal menus without the creative distinctiveness of the top tier), some private bath options alongside communal baths, good locations with reasonable access to the surrounding landscape or city, and a staff ratio that delivers attentive service without the almost overwhelming personal attention of Tier 1.
Tier 2 is appropriate for first-time ryokan guests, for nights that are part of a longer itinerary rather than the centerpiece of a trip, and for travelers who genuinely prefer the social aspect of communal bathing. There is nothing wrong with Tier 2. It is simply a different category with different ceilings.
STANDARD: THE TIER WE DO NOT BOOK
The standard tier, properties priced from ¥15,000 to ¥40,000 per person per night, exists primarily for domestic travel and group tourism. The food is typically set-menu fare that has been optimized for volume rather than quality. The baths are communal and often crowded in peak season. The rooms, while tatami-floored, tend to feel institutional rather than refined. The staff ratio is low.
STAYGO does not recommend standard-tier ryokan to clients. The experience is sufficiently unlike a quality ryokan stay that it risks producing the wrong impression of what the format can be. A traveler who stays at a standard ryokan first and then a Tier 1 property will be startled by the difference. In the reverse order, the standard property simply cannot follow.
WHAT TO LOOK FOR WHEN CHOOSING
Private rotenburo, a private outdoor hot spring bath attached to your room or accessible only by your room's guests, is the most important single factor in choosing a ryokan. It means you can bathe at midnight in a snowfall, for as long as you like, with nobody else there. Properties with private rotenburo for every room (Beniya Mukayu, Gora Kadan) are categorically different from those where it is reserved for suites or where only communal baths exist.
Room type matters significantly. Most ryokan offer a range from standard tatami rooms to full suites with multiple rooms, private gardens, and dedicated attendants. The best room in a good property is dramatically better than the standard room at the same property. STAYGO always secures the best available room category when booking on a client's behalf. It costs more, and of everything in a ryokan booking it is the difference most worth paying for.
Water quality is a genuine differentiator that most booking platforms ignore entirely. Japan's thermal waters vary enormously: sulphurous (Hakone, Noboribetsu), alkaline (Kinosaki, Shirahama), bicarbonate (Arima's gold spring), iron-rich (Arima's silver spring, Beppu). Some waters are better for the skin; some carry stronger medicinal traditions. The water a property sits on is part of what makes it that property, and asking which kind you will be soaking in is a fair question to put before you book.
Guest-to-staff ratio is rarely stated directly but is deducible from room count and price tier. Properties with fewer than 20 rooms at the higher price points almost always deliver a staffing ratio that feels personal. Properties above 40 rooms trend toward the hotel model regardless of their ryokan designation.
TATTOO POLICIES
Many traditional ryokan still prohibit guests with visible tattoos from using shared bath facilities. This policy has deep historical roots in Japan, where tattoos have long been associated with organized crime. While enforcement is inconsistent and cultural attitudes are slowly shifting, particularly in urban properties and among younger staff, the policy remains formally in place at many established properties.
The practical solution for tattooed guests is straightforward: choose a property where private baths are the only option, not an alternative to shared ones. Beniya Mukayu, Gora Kadan, and many other Tier 1 and upper-Tier 2 properties operate exclusively with private baths, so there is no shared bath policy to navigate. STAYGO confirms tattoo policies as part of the property selection process for any client who indicates this is relevant.
HOW STAYGO CHOOSES A RYOKAN
The selection process at STAYGO begins with the client rather than with a shortlist of properties. A traveler who wants to soak outdoors at 3am without another soul present needs a different property from one who wants the traditional shared-bath house, where the morning procession to the communal bath is part of the point. Neither preference is wrong. The ryokan has to match the person.
Once a property is selected, STAYGO secures the best available room category: not the standard room, and not the most expensive option by default, but the room that matches how the client will use the space. A garden suite at Gora Kadan and a standard room at Gora Kadan are two different stays. We also send dietary requirements to the kitchen well before arrival. Kaiseki is built around the season and the chef's plan, but top-tier properties will accommodate serious restrictions if they are told in time.
Finally, STAYGO advises on how many ryokan nights an itinerary should hold. One night at the right property, at the right point in the trip, is worth more than three nights at properties chosen without much thought. For most Japan itineraries the ryokan is the night people remember, so it is worth deciding where it falls.
"A ryokan is not a hotel with tatami. It is a way of looking after a guest, and it is only as good as the people doing it."
WHICH RYOKAN, AND WHICH ROOM
STAYGO matches clients to Tier 1 and Tier 2 ryokan based on how they travel, secures the best room category, and confirms dietary requirements and tattoo policies before you arrive.
Start planning →